History of St Matthew Lutheran Church

History of St Matthew Lutheran Church

"Christian Education is our Business"

From the foundation of St Matthew Lutheran Church, providing our children with a good education with a solid Christian background, has always been a priority.  At the original building, the school was opened before the church structure was finished.  After being closed in the depression, the Lutheran Central School was housed in the same rooms by the Lutheran Education Association, and in 1957 the congregation was blessed to re-establish a school.

Basic Beginnings

1889  -  A meeting was held to organize a new congregation to serve the spiritual needs in this part of North Tonawanda.  The church, then named "St Matthew's German Evangelical Lutheran Church of North Tonawanda" would be built on a piece of land donated by Colonel Lewis S. Payne, a Civil War officer and philanthropist.  The name "St Matthew" (Matthew meaning "God's gift" in Hebrew) was chosen by the forefathers citing Matthew 9:9 where Jesus said, "Follow me."

1890 - On New Year's day 42 communicant members were released from Immanuael Lutheran Church to form the new congregation.   On January 6th, the school opened with 45 children enrolled.  Church services were held in the basement until the church was completed.  It was dedicated in October and Rev. William C. Kloch died just 1 month later, of typhoid fever, serving the young congregation for only 5 months.  Rev. August Hering was installed the following spring


Over the next several years, the young congregation continued to grow.  The cemetary was established on Niagara Falls Boulevard, school enrollment tripled, and an English service was added to the schedule.  Pastor Hering served the congregation for 22 years and died at age 53.  The Rev. Carl A. Frankenstein was installed shortly afterwards.  By 1914 the congregation was debt free.

The Depression

After years of growth, hosting an Eastern District convention, a school addition, new pipe organ, and celebrating its 40th anniversary, the Great Depression hit hard.  The congregation was no longer able to afford to keep the school, and it was closed in 1933, much to the dismay of the members.

The congregation continued to press on.  The church kitchen was remodeled, a garage was added at the parsonage, and the Eastern District convention was held again at the church in 1937.  In 1948, Pastor Frankenstein retired after 35 years service.  Rev. Paul H Gassman was installed in May 1948, and Pastor Frankenstein died just 5 days later.

New Beginnings

Pastor Gassman took a call to another church, and Rev. AW Moldenhauer was installed as pastor in 1955.  The congregation decided in a special voters meeting to re-open the school, and in September 1957, the school season started with 52 children.  The blessings of God on the church were abundant.  A new school wing was added and a new parsonage built.

Elbow Room

By 1967, it was obvious to the congregation that is was outgrowing the building.  The congregation began looking into options to expand or re-locate to a larger structure.  In 1968, a 3 service schedule was started.  In 1971, it was decided a new structure was the needed, and plans were started for our current building.  In 1974, the congregation held its final service in the old building, and walked to the new church.  The building was then dedicated in a festival service.

Continued blessings

Despite a fire that destroyed the new altar and chancel area shortly after Christmas 1977, the congregation was able to hold New Year's Eve Holy Communion service in the church.  Over the next several years, 2 school additions and a gymnasium were added.  The grounds included an athletic field, outdoor altar, bell tower, pavilion and playground.  Shortly after construction of the pavilion, church picinics were held on the grounds, with the service outside at the outdoor altar.  

Changes and Challenges

In 2009, Pastor AW Moldenhauer concluded his ministry at St Matthew, after more than 50 years service and the congregation entered a period of transistion.  Attendance continued to drop as various pastors filled in.  In 2011, the congregation decided that it was no longer necessary to have 2 services, and moved to a single service to help unite the congregation.  The Rev. Gregory Schultz accepted a Call and was installed as pastor in January 2010, but resigned his call in June 2012 for personal health reasons after serving just 2 ½ years.  Pastor Otto Struckman served as regular vacancy pastor until Rev. Steven Naylor accepted the pastoral Call and was installed Jan 2014.

School Suspended

Since 1957, the school had been a fixture and an integral part of St Matthew.  Many parochial schools in the city closed.  The Great Recession of 2008 was hard and the remainder closed.  The school had managed to outlast every other parochial school in North Tonawanda.  However, enrollment was steadily declining over the last decade, and once again the church faced the future without a school.  Enrollment for 2014-2015 was so low the leaders found it was not possible to provide a quality education.  With much anguish, it was decided to suspend the school at a special voters meeting held in May 2014, with the hope of re-opening at least a part of the school in the future.

Looking at the Past and to the Future

In 2015, we looked to remembering our history with 125th Anniversary celebrations taking place throughout the year.  The celebration kicked off with a worship service in the lower hall, meeting the way our founding father's did when the original church was still under construction.  We looked back, and we will looked toward the future.   We looked forward with youth, as baptisms occurred in our church. We helped send youth ministry trips to Haiti in 2015 and Belize in 2016.   The church upgraded systems by replacing the church lighting system and boiler system.   In October 2017, Pastor Naylor accepted a Call to Holy Trinity Lutheran Church, Lutz, Florida, which started a period of 2 years without a regular pastor.  The congregation began an intense search for a new pastor, with the elders sorting through Call lists seeking to find a good match for our church.  The first Call issued by the congregation was declined and returned.  During this time we were blessed to have a pastor leading the service every week, with Pastors Alex Knowles and Mark Aurenhammer leading us through many of the services. Towards the end of the vacancy, there came a couple weeks where no pastors were available, and Elder Rob Pidanick led the service, even preparing and delivering a message.  Rob did so well that he would come to be a backup to fill in when no other pastors were available to fill in for our pastor.

A new pastor and new challenges

Finally, Rev R Blaine Jorg accepted the Call to be our new pastor and was installed in November 2019.  In January 2020, the pastor faced cancer and other health issues.  Just 2 months later the Covid-19 pandemic hit our area, and many businesses and organizations were told by governmental order to limit operations or close.  For the first time in its history, the congregation didn't attended services in the sanctuary for 2 months, missing a portion of Lent and Easter season services.  Despite his healh issues, the pastor remained energenic and resourceful.  For the first time, services and daily devotions were streamed online on Facebook.  The congregation remained resiliant and continued to support the church's mission.  The gym roof was replaced in 2020.  In 2021, the church roof underwent significant repairs, which finally resolved several leaks.  In the fall of 2021, the Rev AW Moldenhauer was called to heaven, potentially leaving the parsonage vacant.  Pastor Blaine and his family made the decision to move again, leaving the house they purchased just 2 years ago, and take up residence in the parsonage.  The congregation was excited to keep the parsonage occupied, the family was excited to be in the parsonage, and the neighbors were excited to make friend with the new family that had moved in.

For more than 130 years, the blessings of God abound.  These are just the highlights, and the congregation certainly had its challenges.  We look forward to the future as we again remember Matthew 9:9, where Jesus says, "Follow Me."